The popular reality TV series “Maine Cabin Masters” has built a loyal audience by showcasing the heartfelt and often nostalgic restoration of rustic cabins across Maine. Led by Chase Morrill and his talented team—including his sister Ashley Morrill, her husband Ryan Eldridge, and crew members like Jedi and Dixie—the show has become a staple on the Magnolia Network. But behind the cozy cabins and scenic views lies a serious legal issue that has raised concerns among fans and regulators alike.
In 2022, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) filed a complaint against the show’s production company, Kennebec Property Services LLC. The reason: alleged violations of the federal Renovation, Repair, and Painting (RRP) Rule, which is designed to prevent lead exposure in homes built before 1978. The lawsuit and its resolution mark a turning point not just for the show but for all televised renovation projects.
What Triggered the Lawsuit
At the heart of the case were five renovation projects conducted in 2020 on homes suspected to contain lead-based paint. According to the EPA, these renovations did not comply with RRP requirements. Specifically, the crew allegedly failed to assign a certified renovator to each project, did not use workers trained in lead-safe practices, and failed to provide proper documentation to homeowners.
These may sound like technical oversights, but the implications are serious. Lead paint, when disturbed, can release harmful particles that pose health risks—particularly to children and pregnant women. The RRP rule mandates stringent protocols to mitigate these risks, and failing to adhere to them can result in significant penalties.
Who Was Involved
While the faces of the show—Chase Morrill, Ashley Morrill, Ryan Eldridge—remain beloved by fans, it was the legal entity behind the scenes, Kennebec Property Services LLC, that bore the brunt of the EPA’s enforcement. Still, because the show operates under this company, the reputation of the cast was indirectly impacted. Public records show that the company settled with the EPA, agreeing to pay a civil penalty of $16,500 and to take corrective actions, including obtaining RRP certification.
Timeline of Events
The renovation work in question took place in 2020. By mid-2021, the EPA had initiated a formal investigation, which continued into 2022. In October 2022, the matter was resolved through a negotiated settlement. The company also agreed to produce public service announcements as part of their show and podcast to raise awareness about lead safety.
Consequences of the Lawsuit
The $16,500 penalty, while relatively modest, serves more as a public warning than a financial blow. More importantly, Kennebec Property Services LLC was required to undergo formal RRP certification and commit to educating the public. As part of their settlement, three future episodes of Maine Cabin Masters will include segments about lead safety. The team also discussed these issues on their podcast From the Woodshed, signaling a commitment to transparency and accountability.
Public and Industry Reaction
Fan reaction was mixed. While many remained loyal to the cast, others expressed disappointment that safety protocols weren’t initially followed. In online forums and social media platforms like Reddit and Facebook, debates ensued about the responsibilities of renovation shows. Industry experts noted that the incident highlights the importance of compliance, even for projects presented in an entertainment context.
Ongoing Questions and Private Complaints
Beyond the EPA lawsuit, a few clients and viewers have raised informal complaints about delays, budgeting inconsistencies, and unmet expectations. Some alleged cost overruns and miscommunication, though no additional lawsuits have been formally filed. Still, these whispers have added to the scrutiny surrounding the show, prompting discussions about ethical transparency in reality TV renovations.
The Bigger Picture
The Maine Cabin Masters lawsuit serves as a critical reminder of the thin line between entertainment and real-world responsibility. Reality shows involving construction must comply with the same laws as any contractor. The EPA’s RRP rule, established to protect health and safety, applies regardless of camera crews and filming schedules.
For homeowners, the lesson is also clear: don’t be dazzled by the romance of TV renovations. Always check that contractors are certified and trained, especially when dealing with older properties. Regulatory compliance isn’t just paperwork—it’s a safeguard for your health.
Chase Morrill and Team: Who Are They?
Chase Morrill, the heart and soul of the crew, is known for his genuine love of Maine’s rustic heritage. In his mid-40s, Chase lives in Augusta, Maine with his family. He stands around 5 feet 10 inches tall and has an approachable, down-to-earth appearance. His sister Ashley Morrill brings a creative edge to the team with her design expertise. Ashley is in her early 40s, married to Ryan Eldridge, and has become a fan favorite thanks to her warm personality and artistic flair.
Ryan Eldridge, Ashley’s husband and the project manager, is also in his 40s and known for his witty humor and practicality. All three cast members have become social media personalities, with thousands of followers on platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube. They regularly interact with fans and promote upcoming episodes, merchandise, and behind-the-scenes content.
Although their individual net worth figures aren’t officially confirmed, estimates suggest that Chase Morrill is worth around $600,000, with Ashley and Ryan not far behind. Their growing brand includes TV earnings, podcast revenue, merchandise sales, and public appearances.
Personalities That Feel Like Family
One of the reasons the lawsuit garnered so much attention is because of how personal the show feels to viewers. The Maine Cabin Masters cast presents themselves not as celebrities but as neighbors—craftspeople restoring dreams, not just cabins. This human connection is what makes the fallout feel more like a family concern than a legal case.
Where Things Stand Now
As of 2025, the show continues to air, and the crew is now fully RRP-certified. Episodes are shot with compliance at the forefront, and safety training is integrated into daily operations. The lawsuit, while a bump in the road, has evolved into a teachable moment—for the team and their millions of fans.
The Maine Cabin Masters brand has emerged with its reputation mostly intact, thanks in part to how seriously the team addressed the allegations. Rather than denying fault, they took corrective action, educated the public, and adapted. That willingness to improve is, in many ways, the most human part of the story.
Final Thoughts
The Maine Cabin Masters lawsuit may not have derailed the show, but it did change its trajectory. With tighter regulations and a greater sense of responsibility, the crew now operates not just as TV personalities but as public figures held to higher standards. In a media landscape often filled with superficial drama, their candid response stands out.
As viewers, we should continue to enjoy the magic of rustic makeovers, but also remember that behind every transformation is a duty to do things right—not just for the camera, but for the community.
READ MORE : Standout Performers in the 76ers vs Washington Wizards Match Player Stats
FAQs
Was the Maine Cabin Masters show canceled because of the lawsuit?
No, the show was not canceled. It continues to air, and the crew has taken steps to comply with all EPA regulations.
What were the main allegations in the lawsuit?
The EPA accused the production company of violating lead safety protocols during renovations on older homes.
Did the cast members face individual legal action?
No. The legal action was directed at the company, Kennebec Property Services LLC, not the individual cast members.
How did the crew respond to the lawsuit?
They paid the fine, completed RRP certification, and pledged to educate viewers about lead safety.
Has the lawsuit affected their popularity?
While some fans were disappointed, the majority supported the team’s efforts to improve and be transparent.
